“Where should I put my savings?” is one of the most common money questions in India, and the usual three answers are a mutual fund SIP, a bank fixed deposit or the Public Provident Fund. Each has a different mix of growth, safety and tax treatment, so the honest answer depends on what you need.
To make the comparison fair, this guide puts the same amount into each one: ₹1,50,000 a year for 15 years, or ₹12,500 a month for the SIP. That is ₹22,50,000 invested in total in every case.
This is an illustration, not investment advice. Returns on mutual funds are not guaranteed, and interest rates and tax rules change. Check current figures before you decide, and speak to a qualified adviser for personal advice.
The numbers side by side
| Option | Assumed return | Value after 15 years | Growth on ₹22.5 lakh |
|---|---|---|---|
| PPF | 7.1% a year, tax-free | ₹40,68,209 | ₹18,18,209 |
| Fixed deposits (new FD each year) | 7% a year, before tax | ₹40,98,543 | ₹18,48,543 |
| Equity SIP | 8% a year | ₹43,54,314 | ₹21,04,314 |
| Equity SIP | 10% a year | ₹52,24,053 | ₹29,74,053 |
| Equity SIP | 12% a year | ₹63,07,200 | ₹40,57,200 |
All figures were calculated with the SIP, FD and PPF calculators, which you can use to try your own amounts.
At first glance the FD and PPF look almost identical, and the SIP looks far ahead. Both impressions need a closer look.
Why tax changes the FD picture
FD interest is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate every year. PPF interest is tax-free. If we reduce the FD’s 7% by the tax you would pay on it each year, the same 15 years look like this:
| FD after tax | Effective return | Value after 15 years |
|---|---|---|
| 20% tax slab | about 5.6% | about ₹36,13,000 |
| 30% tax slab | about 4.9% | about ₹33,96,000 |
So for anyone paying income tax, PPF at 7.1% comes out several lakh rupees ahead of an FD at 7% over 15 years. The higher your tax slab, the bigger the gap.
Why the SIP needs a closer look
An equity SIP has historically grown faster than deposits over long periods, which is why it leads the table. But the return is not guaranteed. Markets fall as well as rise, and a 15-year period can end in a bad year. That is why the table shows 8%, 10% and 12%: the outcome could be any of these, or lower.
SIP gains are also taxed when you sell. For equity mutual funds held more than a year, long-term capital gains above ₹1.25 lakh in a financial year are taxed at 12.5% under the rules in force in 2026. Spread over 15 years and withdrawn sensibly, this usually takes a modest bite, but it is not zero.
The trade-offs in plain words
PPF
- Guaranteed by the Government of India, so the safest of the three.
- Interest and maturity are tax-free. Deposits also qualify for Section 80C if you use the old tax regime.
- Locked for 15 years. Partial withdrawals are allowed from the seventh financial year, and you can extend in blocks of five years.
- Limited to ₹1,50,000 a year, and the rate is reset by the government every quarter.
Fixed deposit
- Very safe. Bank deposits are insured by DICGC up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank.
- Flexible: you choose the tenure and can usually break it early with a small penalty.
- Interest is fully taxable, which hurts most in the higher slabs.
Equity SIP
- Highest growth potential over long periods.
- No guarantee, and the value can drop sharply for months or years.
- Flexible: you can pause, increase or stop at any time, and withdraw whenever you need, though selling during a market fall locks in the loss.
So which one should you choose?
Many people don’t choose just one. A common, sensible approach is:
- Emergency money in a bank or short FD, enough for six months of expenses, because you need it available at any moment.
- PPF for safe, tax-free long-term savings, especially if you are in a higher tax slab.
- SIPs for goals more than seven to ten years away, where you have time to ride out market falls.
The right split depends on your age, income, goals and how you would feel watching an investment fall 20% in a bad year. Use the calculators to test your own numbers: change the monthly amount, the years and the expected return, and see how much difference a few percent makes over a long time.